"A charmingly simple art style celebrates
an entire lifetime, and Kleid's concise script fleshes out the main character efficiently
and effectively." 10/10
Don MacPherson, The Fourth Rail
"Because Kleid has been active in minicomics
and the small press previously, one can't really call this graphic novel a "debut," but if I could, I would say it's the kind of debut that points the way toward an exceptionally bright
future in comics for this creator."
10/10 - BOOK OF THE WEEK
Randy Lander, The Fourth Rail
"...the overall effect is pleasant. I did get involved in the character's life over the
course of those many years, and I was entertained. Really, isn't that all you
can ask for?"
Augie DeBlieck, Comic Book Resources
"Ninety Candles is a perfect introduction to the graphic novel genre...a fantastic and inexpensive add that will add depth to manga and superhero collections and appeal to a broad readership."
The Hip Librarian's Book Blog
"This one sneaks up on you... from a casual little page-turner to a deep, sophisticated story that grabs your heart strings and refuses to let go. Neil Kleid's created a little masterpiece here."
Brian Wood (Channel Zero, Couriers)
"I enjoyed it, it was a novel concept presented in a engaging and formally clever way... it's a very promising book."
Eric Reynolds, Fantagraphics
"I love the idea of a 'cradle to the grave'
book about a cartoonist... really plays
to a lot of my over personal insecurities
as a comic creator - and that's why i think
it is so very effective...There need to be
more comics like this!"
David Gallaher,
YOURS TRULY, JOHNNY DOLLAR
|
"About the most unique graphic novel I've read so far this year, Ninety Candles is a delightful introduction to Kleid's cartooning and at six bucks, is one hell of a bargain."
Alan David Doane, Comic Book Galaxy
"Candles consists of 90 panels, each
representing one year in the life of Kevin
Hall... this gradual process, presented with
an unflinching eye, results in a poignant tale
that could be all too true."
Excerpted from VAMPIRELLA MAGAZINE #4
Boni Alimagno, April/May 2004
"Neil Kleid is set for big things in the comics industry. Ninety Candles is just the beginning of what should prove a long and healthy career."
4.5/5
Scott Wherle, Randomville
"The story rings with pathos, but is by no means tragic. Kevin leaves behind two great creations... Through these creations, Kevin's work and life become sources of inspiration."
Suzette Chan, Sequential Tart
"Glad that I read it...the successes here
are enough that I will definitely want to
read that next project when it's published."
Greg McElhatton, iComics
"...an interesting experiment, a tale
told via crystallized time...It's a touching
story, pretty well done..."
Steven Grant, BADLANDS
"Neil Kleid's Ninety Candles chronicles the life of a dreamer and the cost of making dreams come true. He uses one panel to depict each year of his protagonists life, and somehow that crazy format works! It's well-written, well-drawn, and I recommend it to anyone who makes comics, wants to make comics, or wants to understand a cartoonist."
Jim Rugg (Street Angel)
|
